The Winter Rose by Jennifer Donnelly

515NClT-cEL._SX312_BO1,204,203,200_Fiction — print. Hyperion Books, 2009. Originally published 2006. 720 pgs. Purchased.

As much as I loved the first book in Donnelly’s series, it took me a couple of years to read the second book because I had heard the book followed different characters from those introduced in the first novel.

That’s not entirely true; Fiona and Joe do make multiple appearances in the second novel. But the focus is on India Selwyn Jones, an idealistic, newly graduated doctor living in London between 1900 and 1906.

India is desperate to change the lives of the poor people of East London. Armed with pamphlets on nutrition and child raising, India is convinced she knows what’s best for people living on round about a pound a week. She’s in for a rude awakening, however, when she comes into direct conflict with East London’s ruling crime lord — Sid Malone.

Malone’s activities and knowledge of the people of East London open India’s eyes to the real problems of poverty and help fuel her dreams of opening a free clinic for women and children of the area. India’s influential fiance — Freddie Lytton, an up-and-coming MP — will stop at nothing to marry India and gain her family’s fortune.

Riddled with cliches? Yes. But I just could not put the novel down despite it being over 700 pages. Sid’s brother and his mountain climbing love affair could have been left out. I willing to bet this was included because the third book in the series will cover Seamus and Willis, but I just wasn’t interested in a new story halfway through the book when the rest of the characters were already established.

The characters are all very endearing. I loved reading India’s transition from an idealistic young woman hell bent on reforming things she does not know to a doctor with a greater understanding of her patients.

Overall, this is a good book. Not as good as the first book and if the third book is going to be about Seamus and Willis, I’m not sure if I will read or not. But I am glad I picked up the second book in the series!


  1. I have Winter Rose on my shelf. I somehow ended up with the second book and not the first. Do I need to read the first book first? It sounds like it was better, so maybe I should!


    • I would recommend reading the first book not just because it was better in my opinion, but because it lays out the back story and motivations of Sid Malone’s actions.


  2. I’ve been waiting for over 3 weeks for bookdepository to deliver this one. I also loved the first, but waited months until deciding to order the second.

    Always liked Sid Malone in the first book so I’m glad she’s focusing on him. The next in the series will focus on the younger brother, I imagine? I will be launched soon.


    • I hope it shows up soon, Alex! And, yes, I do think the third book will be about the youngest brother. Unfortunately, as I said above, his mountain climbing adventures didn’t really capture my attention so I don’t know if I will read it or not.


  3. Pingback: The Winter Rose by Jennifer Donnelly « The Sleepless Reader

Please feel free to share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: